What good is MSE anyway?
Delrin is a low-friction plastic that is extremely machineable; Delrin parts can be made on a laser cutter or mill. For small, precise parts, the Othermill is a great way to machine Delrin. Delrin is fairly strong, although it will deform substantially under higher loads.
Acrylic (in the form that Jacobs Hall sells) is a fairly brittle material that we recommend avoiding for use in flight parts. Acrylic is occaisionally useful for enclosures or signs. Polycarbonate is recommended as a substitute for acrylic unless the material must be laser cut.
ABS is a common 3D-printing plastic. It is slightly more ductile than PLA, the other common printing plastic, but otherwise similar. While there is a common perception that ABS is "stronger" than PLA, this is somewhat inaccurate; for most uses, they are indistinguishable.
6061 aluminum is a fairly machinable material that can be processed with a waterjet cutter, bandsaw, fiber laser cutter, mill, lathe, and/or welding machine. Compared to most plastics and wood, aluminum is very strong; consider using aluminum for parts where strength is more important than weight. Aluminum is fairly soft, so do not design parts that require threads to be cut into aluminum; instead, use threaded inserts. We generally use the 6061 alloy, but others are acceptable; check with an expert before making the decision to use another alloy.
This is the material we are currently using for our thrust chamber. Otherwise, generally avoid brass as there are better and cheaper substitutes available (usually aluminum).
Jacobs Hall sells plywood in several sizes and thicknesses for laser cutting. Common thicknesses are 0.25 in and 0.125 in. It is important to note that wood is anisotropic; its material properties vary significantly according to the direction of the forces applied. Wood can be used for structural parts, but it may be better to consider Lexan and aluminum first. Jacobs plywood is often used to make non-structural jigs, holders, etc.
Lexan is extremely strong, although it will flex slightly under load. Most of our Lexan parts are produced with a waterjet cutter, although they can be milled, bored, etc. afterward if needed. We are unable to cut Lexan with lasers; if laser cutting is desired and strength is not a priority, consider using Delrin instead.
PLA is a bio-based plastic commonly used for 3D printing. It is slightly more brittle than ABS, but it can absorb more energy before failure. See the "Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS)" entry for a comparison of PLA with ABS. It is also more readily available than any other 3D printing materials in the Jacobs Hall Makerspace. PLA is a good candidate for parts with complex geometry that are non-structural in nature. It is important to note that printed parts, like wood, are anisotropic; they fail much more easily in some directions (along layer lines) than others.
ESRA guidelines say we pretty much can't use stainless steel for anything important. That being said, other projects or non-critical parts might be allowed to use stainless steel; check the regulations! Many low-strength fasteners are made out of 18-8 stainless.
ABS
PLA
ABS printers at Jacobs have soluble supports
Usually not available with soluble supports at Jacobs
Much higher tendency to warp, especially without enclosed, heated build envelope
Doesn't warp nearly as much
ABS printers at Jacobs are much higher resolution than the Type A / Ultimaker
Type A prints are typically the worst quality achievable, Ultimakers are slightly better
Parts may bend instead of breaking, higher elongation at break
May crack if dropped, rather than bending, but higher tensile strength
Dimensions and Fortus are limited and often in use, may require joining a lengthy queue
Type A and Ultimakers are more plentiful and more frequently free, with low turnaround time
Free at Jacobs
Fumes may give you cancer, kills the planet
Food-safe, biodegradable (with 6 months in a specialized composting facility, don't worry)
Gets softer at slightly lower temperatures
Requires Jacobs hands-on training
On-line training only needed
Little ABS personally owned by team members
In-stock at homes of team members for printing
Costs at least at Jacobs; parts are free
Glass transition at a slightly higher temperature (~ higher)
